Press Releases

Jeffrey Lashley, 9/11/59 of Cedar Key, FL was arrested on July 1, 2025 for multiple violations of the sexual predator registration requirements. In 1996 Lashley was convicted for Lewd and Lascivious Battery. This conviction designated him a Sexual Offender in the State of Florida.

In 2004, having been arrested again for sexually based crimes against children, Lashley was again convicted thus designating him a Sexual Predator. It is based on these convictions and the age of the victim(s) that he was required to register as a Sexual Offender/ Predator for life.

Lashley’s newest violations this year were discovered when Detective Cody Weaver performed a sexual predator compliance check at his home in Cedar Key. Detective Weaver identified a smart phone in Lashley’s possession. Detective Weaver knew Lashley had not registered this device.

A search of this phone discovered that Lashley had multiple social media applications installed on the phone. He was also required to disclose any social media sites he subscribed to during his registration. Lashleys phone was discovered to contain numerous images of Child Sexual Abuse Material he later admitted to downloading from the internet. Lashley phone additionally contained recently taken pictures of young juvenile females in bathing suits. It appears these photographs were taken at several public places in our community.

Detectives also seized numerous paper notebooks from Lashley. These contained writings that described explicit stories and/or his fantasies of him performing sexual acts on children, both male and female. It appeared he fantasized about children between the ages of four to 10 years old. The evidence and documentation was overwhelming which would aid our prosecuting team the evidence to secure a conviction.

Faced with the reality of the case against him, Lashley entered an open plea on 8/27/25 to Circuit Judge William Davis, seeking leniency. Judge Davis appropriately sentenced him to a prison term of 30 years in the Florida Department of Corrections.

8/29/25

On 9/8/24, Shawn Orr (7/27/63) called 911 to report that he located his wife, Eloida Davis, deceased. Orr directed responding emergency units to a wooded area along a secondary driveway to their home where her body was located. Orr quickly became the person of interest in his wife’s death. Evidence revealed a violent abusive relationship.

The entire team of the LCSO Criminal Investigations Division pursued every lead and recovered evidence that Orr and his wife had a violent physical altercation inside their home the night before. Broken furniture along with blood evidence was recovered from the home, debunking Orr’s statement she walked away uninjured earlier the night prior. Orr claimed during his efforts to locate her, he accidentally ran over her remains while turning around.  It appeared Orr intentionally ran her remains over to conceal her injuries he inflicted the night before. Detective Ryan Sullivan placed Orr under arrest for murder.

Orr, who has remained in custody since his arrest, entered an open plea on 8/27/25 to Circuit Judge William Davis who sentenced Orr to 30 years. Orr will be transported to the Florida Department of Corrections to begin serving his sentence for the murder of his wife, Eloida.

Tanner McDaniel

8/27/25            

In December of 2024, Detective Blake Landfair was assigned to investigate an accusation of sexual misconduct made against Tanner McDaniel (11/1/92).  McDaniel, a church youth leader, allegedly engaged in an inappropriate relationship with one of his students. The investigation uncovered convincing physical, electronic, and testimonial evidence. A warrant was obtained for McDaniel’s arrest, and McDaniel was arrested 1/11/25.

On 8/20/25, McDaniel entered an open plea to the Circuit Judge William Davis who sentenced McDaniel to 4 years in the Florida Department of Corrections. Upon his release he will serve an additional 10 years of sex offender probation, and must register as a sex offender for the remainder of his life.

Sexual based crimes perpetrated against children are some of the most difficult to investigate. The detectives at the LCSO are relieved the victim and family were spared the additional trauma of a trial. Now we hope and pray for the continued healing of this victim.

8/29/25

On 8/19/24, Brandon Tyler Capozzi (4/26/94) drove his motorcycle to victim, Carry Weeks’ property and shot him when Weeks walked down his driveway to speak to him. Capozzi immediately fled the location. LCSO Deputies and Detectives immediately responded to the shooting scene and quickly identified Capozzi as the primary suspect. Detectives left no lead unchecked in their attempt to locate Capozzi.

Capozzi was ultimately tracked down and taken into custody in the Williston McDonalds parking lot within hours of the incident. Detectives interviewed Capozzi who made a full confession for his crime. Detectives also learned valuable information on where he hid the firearm used during his crime. This gun was recovered ensuring it would never be used to commit another crime. Capozzi was charged with murder and evidence tampering and has been held in LCSO’s custody since the date of his arrest.

On 8/27/25, the Honorable 8^th Judicial Circuit Judge William Davis sentenced Capozzi to 35 years in the Florida Department of Corrections for premeditated murder and evidence tampering. His prison sentenced will be followed by 10 years of probation. The LCSO’s hope is that this lengthy sentence brings a semblance of peace to the victim’s family and friends. We also want to offer a special thankyou to the Williston Police Department who played a major role in Capozzi’s capture at McDonalds and recovery of vital evidence. 

• Burglary (from the outstanding warrant) – Bond: $75,000
• Resisting Arrest – Bond: $2,500

August 22, 2025

Deputy Rich Peters was on patrol in Bronson on August 17^th and stopped a Jeep for excessive speed. The driver, identified as Otis R. Johnson (9/6/77) of Bronson was extremely nervous. Deputy Peters smelled to odor of burned marijuana coming from inside the vehicle and asked Johnson if he had a prescription for this substance. Johnson said he did not.

The roadside investigation determined Johnson was operating a rental vehicle assigned to a third person who was not present with him. Johnson said there could be marijuana in the vehicle that belonged to the person who actually rented it and gave permission to search and locate the marijuana.

The search found much more than marijuana. Deputy Peters located over 100 grams of methamphetamines, ammunition and a large sum of cash. Johnson was placed under arrest and this investigation also determined he is a previously convicted felon and prohibited from possessing a firearm and/or ammunition.

Johnson has been charged with trafficking in methamphetamines, possession of ammunition by a convicted felon and possession of drug paraphernalia. He is being held in the Levy County Detention Center and his bond has been set at $135,000.00.

August 14, 2025

On May 30, 2024 Justin Bryant (6/29/88) of Morriston embarked on a drug fueled mission of murder. In a short time frame he brutally stabbed and cut four people in a normally quiet Morriston neighborhood. No clear cut motive for this crime was ever established. Thankfully no life was lost but these victims have lived with the scars he caused, both physically and mentally.

Bryant has been held in the Levy County Detention Center awaiting trial since his arrest. Recently, he entered an “open” plea of guilty to 8^th Judicial Circuit Judge Davis, hoping for leniency in his sentence. Due to the brutality of this crime, little leniency was granted. Judge Davis sentenced Bryant to 40 years in the Florida Department of Corrections.

This case saw a massive response from law enforcement. At the time our 911 system began flooding with emergency calls while Bryant was still at large and potentially injuring other innocent people. All on duty available Levy County deputies responded. Williston Police Department sent all of their available officers. The manhunt was intense and Bryant was quickly located by a Williston Police Officer and a Levy County Deputy. The extraordinary cooperative work between our agencies allowed for this quick apprehension potentially saving more lives. So, a special thank you is warranted to Chief Rolls and all the officers at the Williston Police Department for their unwavering commitment to keeping the Levy County community safe.  

Faithful Partner • Loyal Protector • Heroic Heart

End of Watch: 8/5/2025

It is with heavy hearts that we announce the passing of Canine Deputy Molly. She was a dedicated drug detection dog and beloved partner to Detective Gary Garboski.  They served side by side for over seven years.

Molly began her service with the Levy County Sheriff’s Office in 2017. A highly trained and fiercely intelligent working dog, she joined the force and quickly became an invaluable member of the department. Throughout her career, she assisted in countless investigations, helping to remove dangerous substances from our streets and ensuring the safety of our community. Her work led to numerous arrests, the seizure of illegal narcotics, and—most importantly—the saving of lives. Molly and Detective Garboski were assigned to the Patrol Division where they quickly proved themselves to be an effective and dedicated team.

Molly and Detective Garboski transferred to the Drug Task Force Unit in 2019 where they continued impactful work in the fight against illegal narcotics. Molly loved her job and lived for the reward of chasing her toy. Off duty, she was a beloved member of Detective Garboski’s family and spent her time surrounded by love and companionship.

Molly was more than just a working dog—she was a loyal partner, a valued teammate, and truly the best dog ever. Molly passed peacefully with her partner and family by her side, honored until the very end. Her presence will be deeply missed by Detective Garboski, his family and everyone at the Levy County Sheriff’s Office.

Rest easy, K-9 Molly. Your watch is over. We have the watch now. You served with honor and heart.